Title Searches and Title Insurance in Plain English

    The short answer: A title search checks the public records to confirm who owns a property and what claims, such as unpaid mortgages, liens, judgments or easements, affect it. Title insurance is a policy, paid for once at closing, that protects against covered title problems from before the purchase. Lenders usually require a lender's policy. An owner's policy, which protects the buyer, is generally optional (CFPB).

    Here's how the pieces fit together in a New Jersey sale, and where agents come in.

    What is "title," and what can go wrong with it?

    Title is legal ownership. The deed is the document that transfers it. Problems come from the past: a previous owner's unpaid taxes, or a contractor who says they weren't paid for work done before the sale, can become claims against the home (CFPB).

    New Jersey's homebuyer guide from the Department of Banking and Insurance says most purchase agreements are conditioned on a title search covering liens and judgments, including whether the seller is in bankruptcy. If someone else has a claim, the seller's title isn't "clear," and the guide says the buyer isn't obligated to finish the purchase. It tells buyers that their real estate attorney can evaluate the title and advise them (NJ DOBI, Everything You Wanted to Know about Buying a Home). Your actual rights depend on the contract, so treat that as general guidance.

    What does a title search look for?

    A searcher works back through recorded documents tied to the property. Typical findings:

    FindingExampleUsual fix
    Open mortgageThe seller's loanPaid off from the seller's proceeds at closing
    Lien or judgmentTax lien, contractor's lien, court judgmentPaid, released or bonded before closing
    EasementUtility line, shared drivewayDisclosed; usually stays with the land
    RestrictionDeed or HOA limits on useDisclosed; buyer decides if acceptable
    Survey issueFence or shed over the lineResolved, or listed as an exception
    Ownership gapA missing heir, or a probate issueCorrective deed or court process

    The PSI exam outline lists "potential title problems and resolutions" and "marketable and insurable title" under Transfer of Title (PSI bulletin). Marketable title is title a reasonable buyer would accept without fear of a lawsuit. Insurable title is title a company is willing to insure, sometimes with exceptions.

    Does New Jersey law require a search before a policy?

    Yes. Under the state's Title Insurance Act, no title policy may be written until the insurer has had a reasonable examination of the title conducted and made a determination of insurability under sound underwriting practices. Evidence of that work is kept for at least 15 years (N.J.S.A. 17:46B-9).

    What is a title commitment?

    Before closing, the title company issues a commitment: its promise to insure, subject to listed requirements (such as paying off the old mortgage) and exceptions (things the policy won't cover). New Jersey adds a consumer notice. Unless the applicant is a NJ attorney representing the buyer, or the insured is a government body, the title company must mail the proposed insured a notice, at least 5 days before closing. The notice says the commitment may contain conditions, exceptions and limitations, and that the buyer may review it with an attorney of their choosing before title transfers (N.J.S.A. 17:46B-9).

    The exceptions are where to look first. Anything listed there isn't covered.

    What's the difference between an owner's policy and a lender's policy?

    Lender's policyOwner's policy
    ProtectsThe lender's loanThe buyer's ownership and equity
    Required?Usually, to get a mortgageGenerally optional
    CoveragePays the lender the remaining loan principal on a covered, unresolved problemTypically up to the full purchase price
    On the Loan EstimateListed as a title costMarked "optional" when the lender doesn't require it

    Sources: CFPB, lender's title insurance; U.S. Treasury; CFPB TRID title factsheet.

    The key point for buyers: a lender's policy doesn't protect the owner's equity. If someone brings a claim against the home, the owner is the first one responsible (CFPB). Both policies are paid with a one-time premium at closing (U.S. Treasury).

    Who sets the price in New Jersey?

    Every title insurer must file its schedule of fees and rating manuals with the Commissioner of Banking and Insurance, either on its own or through a licensed rating organization. It may not charge except under the rates in effect for it (N.J.S.A. 17:46B-42). The CFPB says you can usually shop for a title provider separately from your mortgage, and buying both policies from the same provider usually costs less in total (CFPB).

    Can the seller pick the buyer's title company?

    Not as a condition of the sale when the buyer uses a federally related mortgage loan. Federal law bars the seller from requiring, directly or indirectly, that the buyer purchase title insurance from a particular company. A seller who does is liable to the buyer for three times the title insurance charges (12 U.S.C. 2608).

    Why should agents understand title?

    Title touches the contract, the timeline and your client's money. Title problems can delay a closing, a contract's title provisions decide what happens if title isn't clear, and the referral rules for settlement services apply to you. The glossary defines other closing terms, contingencies explains the other conditions buyers rely on, and the attorney review guide covers the first days after signing. Kickback rules are in the financing exam guide.

    Title and closing are part of the 75 hours of pre-licensing education every NJ agent completes. Business Elementary's 75-hour pre-licensing course page explains that first step.

    Sources

    Last reviewed: October 28, 2026

    Related guides:

    Frequently Asked Questions